Hi Tim, You have a primary and dual water inlet valve, since the water dispenser is working that indicates the primary water inlet valve is good. The dual one sends water to the water dispenser and to the ice maker.
Both of these water inlet valves are in the back of your refrigerator. The dual one should be located behind the single one, it will have a small plastic cover over it that is held on by 1 screw, just remove that screw to get that cover off the dual one.
Here's the OEM single(primary) water inlet valve for your model:
WPW10238100 Valve
Here's the OEM dual(secondary) water inlet valve for your model:
Water Inlet Valve WPW10341320
BUT FIRST--->Check your wire harness under the freezer door and see if you have any cut wires preventing 120 volts going to the ice maker side(smaller diameter hose) of your dual water water inlet valve.
Another member was having a similar problem here:
FIXED: GSF26C4EXY02 Whirlpool Gold Ice Maker Problem
Look at his post #6 he found
frayed and broken wires underneath the freezer door, I'd remove your kickplate and check for that first.
Here's another one with the same thing about the frayed and broken wires:
FIXED: 106.51173310 Kenmore elite ice maker not working - no led light
Here's another:
FIXED: Whirlpool WSF26C2EXF01 Door Icemaker Not Working
ALSO, remove the black loom from the wire harness directly under the freezer door, I've seen wires ARE broken/frayed there too.